Journal of Environmental Treatment Techniques  
2019, Volume 7, Issue 3, Pages: 370-376  
Mathematical and Instrumental Methods for  
Assesing the Economic Efficiency of Science  
Product for Export  
1
2
3
Svetlana V. Veretekhina *, Maxim A. Kudryavtsev , Vladimir L. Simonov , Sergey A.  
4
5
Makushkin , Tatyana V. Karyagina  
1
Department of Information Systems, Networks and Security, Russian State Social University, Moscow, Russia, E-mail:  
veretehinas@mail.ru  
2
Direction of Preparation Mathematical Support of Computers, Complex and Computer Networks, Russian State Social University,  
Moscow, Russia, E-mail: kudryavtsevma@yandex.ru  
3
Department of Information Systems, Networks and Security, Russian State Social University, Moscow, Russia, E-  
mail:SimonovVL@rgsu.net  
4
Department of HR Management and HR Policy, Russian State Social University, Moscow, Russia, E-mail: MakashkinSA@rgsu.net  
Department of Mathematics and Computer Science, Faculty of Information Technologies, Faculty of Information Technologies,  
5
Russian State Social University, Moscow, Russia, E-mail: zolinatv@mail.ru  
Received: 03/04/2019  
Accepted: 10/08/2019  
Published: 20/08/2019  
Abstract  
The relevance of the study is due to the needs of using standardized Russian methods of calculating the unit cost of maintenance  
of exported science-intensive products. The authors bring to the discussion the hypothesis that the price of the exported science-  
intensive products does not dominate in the market however technologies of information support of science-intensive products at the  
object of operation dominate. Exporting a series of products to Indonesia is described by the calculations of maintenance examples at  
the facility. The methods of measurement, description and modeling were used in the calculations. In the first part of the article,  
authors classify the activities of the integrated logistics support and the elements of the maintenance Scenario. Calculations are based  
on the list of the main Russian standards for exporting products. The indicators for the assessment of initial maintenance cost are  
defined. The article determines the effective use of science-intensive products at the site of operation possibility in the presence of  
trained technical personnel from the customer's country (Indonesia). The calculations determine the number of specialties of  
engineering staff required to perform maintenance and repair the product. Mathematical modeling service cost of the service is  
carried out for the products delivered for export. The purpose of the article is to reduce the cost of the service maintenance on the  
territory of the Customer (Indonesia), in terms of reducing the technical personnel training cost. The calculation methods  
recommended by Russian national standard GOST R 56130-2014 was used in the article. The research was aimed at identifying  
unnecessary cost, while maintaining the performance quality of the product at the facility. The calculations show how to use  
standardized methods effectively. The main purpose of this publication is to develop methodological provisions for the analysis of  
economic processes and systems based on the use of economic and mathematical methods and tools.  
Keywords: Methods of Unit Cost Calculation, Efficiency, Integrated Logistics Support, Mathematical Modeling, Cooperation  
between Russia and Indonesia.  
1
Indonesia. Indonesia doesn’t have land borders with other  
1
1
Introduction  
countries. The commander-in-chief of the National army of  
Indonesia determines the need for the purchase of military  
aircrafts (message was published on Janes.com). The required  
aircrafts are heavy, medium and light, as well as cargo  
transport aircraft, helicopters. From the materials of Peter  
Arkhipov, the Government of Indonesia plans to cooperate  
with Russian Federation. The head of the Indonesian Agency  
R. Ryacudu (4,6,8,16) expressed interest in buying Russian  
.1 Political Review of Indonesia  
Indonesia consists of scattered Islands washed by the  
Pacific and Indian ocean. There are no foreign armies in  
Corresponding author: Svetlana V. Veretekhina,  
Department of Information Systems, Networks and Security,  
Russian State Social University, Moscow, Russia, E-mail:  
veretehinas@mail.ru.  
370  
Journal of Environmental Treatment Techniques  
2019, Volume 7, Issue 3, Pages: 370-376  
army aircraft “SU series”. The contract is estimated in $1.1  
billion. The lending deal fell under U.S. sanctions, named:  
CAATSA (Countering America’s Adversaries Through  
Sanctions Act) ("ON opposition to America's opponents  
through sanctions»). The difficult financial situation came to  
Indonesia in October 2018.It was planned to hold an  
exhibition with the participation of leading politicians,  
Ministers, representatives of the Government of the countries.  
International Asian Exhibition Defense & Security 2019 will  
be held from 18 to 21 November in Bangkok. It’s planning to  
discuss the issues of security management, the fight against  
terrorism, the development of defense technologies.  
hypothesis that the price of the exported science-intensive  
products doesn’t dominate on the market however  
technologies of information support of science-intensive  
products at the object of operation dominate. The customer  
must have methods for calculation and the ability to simulate  
the cost of providing information support for the purchased  
products. We will determine the requirements of domestic  
and international standards for the supplying exporting  
products. On the meeting of the technical Committee for  
standardization TC 482 "Support of exported military  
products and dual-use products" members of the technical  
Committee discussed issues of integrated logistics support for  
exporting products. In the ROE (Rosoboronexport) letter  
dated November 3, 2017 in the agenda included issues, the  
solution of which provides Russian's access to the  
international markets for the supply of high-tech exporting  
products. The main problems identified by the Technical  
Committee are:  
1
.2 Economic Review of Indonesia  
The ranking of countries by GDP in 2019 based on the  
forecast data of the International Monetary Fund. Indonesia  
placed on the 112 rank GDP per capital in the world 2018  
(table 1).  
problems of normative and technical supporting of  
Table 1: Gross Domestic Product on the human population in the  
world at 2018  
the complex science-intensive products life cycle and their  
solutions;  
Country  
Algeria  
Mongolia  
Indonesia  
Gross Domestic Product  
4270.98  
problems of processes standardization for computer  
1
1
1
10  
11  
12  
design technologies, mathematical modeling, simulation  
programs and modeling kits;  
4182.09  
4178.86  
problems of cataloging in the management system of  
after-sales service for high-tech products at the facilities;  
Problems of the methodological supporting on the  
The major financial institutions predict that Gross  
Domestic Product of Indonesia will increase on 5.4% from  
018 to 2019. The Indonesian Armed forces have  
basis of integrated logistics support and cataloging.  
2
Leading experts of the Technical Committee doctor of  
technical Sciences E.V. Sudov, chairman Y.K. Demchenko,  
candidate of technical Sciences. A.N. Petrov worked out the  
directions of the further work for ensuring the  
competitiveness of high-tech products in the international  
market. It should be noted that the value of the product on  
the international market does play a key role. In the  
international market competitive products are those that have  
a long, standardized cycle of information support on the  
customer's territory.  
considerable potential; however, it is not enough to ensure the  
country's defense. This is not manifested as a priority issue  
due to the lack of direct external threats at the moment," said  
Alexander Khramchikhin, Deputy Director of the Institute of  
political and military analysis.  
2
Methodological Framework  
Mathematical methods assess the science-intensive  
products for suppling export. They include a comprehensive  
analyze of the supporting processes on the science-intensive  
products at the facility in the customer country (Indonesia).  
Complex analysis includes calculations confirming the  
effectiveness of material, financial, labor and time resources.  
In the article, the selected series of products with the formal  
name of the exported products - SU2MKI-refers to the  
knowledge-intensive products supplied for export. Since the  
name of the SU2MKI product does not play a role in the  
assessing the economic efficiency of the maintenance of  
science-intensive products abroad, the main a priority data  
are: the number of exported products, the frequency of  
delivering the spare parts and equipment under warranty and  
post-warranty repairing contracts. It's also important to  
control the time period of service, the complexity of service,  
as well as the remoteness of the country of export. Different  
countries for the supply of science-intensive products exhibit  
requirements in accordance with the current requirements of  
international standards for the supply of knowledge-based  
products and their supporting directly at the facility  
The concept of a long cycle includes: warranty (2-3  
years), post-warranty (3-5 years) maintenance and repair (10  
years) of high-tech products in the Customer country  
(
Indonesia).  
Russian authors E.V. Sudov et al. in the training manual  
Technologies of integrated logistics support in the life cycle  
"
of knowledge-intensive products of aviation equipment"  
consider the analyze of logistics supporting (ILP) as a one of  
the basic technologies (15).  
The tenth issue of the electronic journal "PLM and ILP  
technologies" provides publications the topics about creating  
subsystems for solving resource management problems in the  
integrated logistics support system, exampled by the reactor  
plants. The ninth issue of the electronic journal "PLM and  
ILP technologies" provides publications about "Modern  
technologies and standards of integrated logistics support  
(ILP) in product development processes" authored by the  
E.V. Sudov et al. (14). In the article authors analyze the  
current state of standards for the usage of the integrated  
logistics support analyze database (ALP) during the  
development solutions for the technical operation and  
development operational documentation.  
(Indonesia).  
The main purpose of this publication is to develop  
methodological provisions for the analysis of economical  
processes and systems based on the usage of economic and  
mathematical methods and tools. The authors discuss the  
371  
Journal of Environmental Treatment Techniques  
2019, Volume 7, Issue 3, Pages: 370-376  
Russian authors A.S. Aktymbayeva et al. the main idea  
E-commerce evaluation and e-business trends. Of the analysis  
carried out by the authors is the identification of the full-scale  
usage of the ASD (aerospace and defense industry of Europe  
testing at the facility, the usage in the different modes of  
operation, run to break. The quality of ensuring operability of  
the product at the facility depends on the following  
parameters: material and labor resources; maintenance work;  
downtime costs; under-delivery or excessive supply of spare  
parts of the product, tools and accessories, the availability of  
high qualified technical personnel, information support for  
decision-making in the case of trouble-free life of the  
product. Integrated logistics support activities include  
elements of a maintenance Scenario displayed in the table 2.  
-
ASD) specifications (1). Compliance with the requirements  
for the European international specification (aerospace and  
defense industry of Europe - ASD) offers the usage the sets  
of specialized specifications. Authors V.A. Barinova et al.  
analysis of competitive factors of domestic high-tech  
companies (2). The need for IT-standardization, it was noted  
by the authors E.V. Blyaeva and A.V. Gavrilov (3). Authors  
E.A. Khitskov et al. note the need for new methods in the era  
of Digital economy and digital transformation of society(7).  
The application of integrated logistics support standards  
allows to ensure the effective usage of high-tech products on  
the acceptable level. An acceptable cost of service at the  
facility will depends on the scenario of the use of high-tech  
products by the customer countries. The scenario for the  
usage of the science-intensive products includes several  
stages of operation with the product: run-in, run-through,  
Table  
2
shows that the planning of Technical  
maintenance (MTO) for the product at the facility contains  
the main elements: the development of requirements for the  
periodicity planned MAINTENANCE; development of  
material and technical support (MTO); development the  
operational documentation (interactive, e-document),  
development the standards of the transportation for the  
product on the facility; development the resource  
requirements. National standards for integrated logistics  
supporting the exporting products are presented in Table 3.  
Table 2: Activities at the integrated logistic support (ILS), and scenario technical service (STS)  
Type of activity ILS  
Development  
Maintenance  
Perfection  
/
element STS  
Development of requirements  
for the composition and  
frequency of scheduled  
maintenance  
Recommendations for adaptation of the  
requirements to the composition and  
frequency of maintenance subject to the  
conditions of operating organizations  
Recommendations for improvement  
of requirements to the composition  
and the frequency maintenance  
service(MS)  
Planning maintenance  
service (MS) /Plan  
maintenance service (MS)  
Planning material and  
technical service (MTS)/  
Plan MTS  
Directory development,  
Catalogue MTS  
Recommendations for the application of  
the maintenance plan  
Plan adjustment MTS  
Development maintenance  
documentation (MD)  
Development and delivery  
maintenance documentation  
Elimination of operational documentation  
inaccuracies at the operational stage  
Changes to the maintenance  
documentation (MD  
/
Maintenance  
(MD)  
documentation  
Development of  
Verification of compliance of means of  
operation with the developed  
requirements  
requirements for means of  
operation /Means of  
operation  
Development of requirements  
for means of operation  
Changes to requirements  
Development of  
Verification of personnel compliance with  
the specified requirements,  
recommendations  
requirements for the  
number, specialization and  
qualification of personnel  
Determination of requirements  
to the number, specialization  
and qualification of personnel  
Adjustment of personnel requirements  
To resolv inconsistencies  
/
Personnel  
Table 3: List of main standards of exported products  
Appointment  
The name of the standard of the Russian  
Federation  
Russian national standard  
ГОСТР 55932-2013  
integrated logistics support (ILS) of exported military products. Operational and repair documentation.  
Delivery and modification requirements  
Russian national standard  
ГОСТР 56111-2014  
integrated logistics support (ILS) exported military products. Nomenclature of performance and  
technical characteristics  
Russian national standard  
ГОСТР 56113-2014  
integrated logistics support (ILS) exported military products. Logistics planning  
Russian national standard  
ГОСТР 56114-2014  
integrated logistics support (ILS) exported military products. Requirements for the analysis of logistics  
support of exported military products  
Russian national standard  
ГОСТР 56130-2014  
integrated logistics support support (ILS) of exported military products. Estimation of technical  
operation costs at the development stage  
Table 3 shows that the Russian national standards for  
integrated logistics support include: planning of logistics,  
requirements for the analyze for logistics supporting for  
exported products, cost estimation, requirements for changes.  
The ROE website presents partner countries for the  
suppling of the high-tech products. Russian arms  
geographical exports include: Asia, Africa, Europe.  
Cooperation with Indonesia indicated by the diplomatic  
relations established with Russia since February 3, 1950.  
372  
Journal of Environmental Treatment Techniques  
2019, Volume 7, Issue 3, Pages: 370-376  
ꢇꢈꢉ  
Indonesia and Russia have signed an agreement on mutually  
beneficial cooperation in the political, economic, cultural and  
military fields. The Business Cooperation Council,  
established on 10 November 2009, is an effective mechanism.  
The countries signed about 20 intergovernmental agreements,  
which form the basis of economic cooperation between  
Russia and Indonesia. The countries have signed an  
Agreement on military-technical cooperation in 2010. In this  
case, emphasis should be placed on technical cooperation.  
Technical cooperation is possible if customer the country  
ꢆꢀ  
ꢊꢋꢃꢁꢌ- the number of specialists of the i-th  
specialty - 5 required for technical service and repair (TSP)  
copies;  
ꢅꢍꢎꢏ  
specialty  
- the cost of training specialist i-th  
ꢀ
ꢄꢅ- the unit price of one technical service  
system (TSS) of the i-th type  
ꢀ
3
Materials and Methods  
The use of standards of integrated logistics support by  
foreign customers allows to ensure the effective use of high-  
tech products at an acceptable cost of its life cycle at the  
facility.  
The state standard of the Russian Federation recommends  
the use of calculation methods.  
(Indonesia) applies the requirements of standards for  
providing information support for high-tech products at the  
facilities. GOST R 56130-2014 "Assessment of technical  
operation costs at the development stage" was developed by  
JSC "Research center "Applied logistics", approved and put  
into effect by the Order of the Federal Agency for regulation  
and Metrology of September 19, 2014 № 1150-art.  
The main methods of calculation are:  
1
. The method of calculating the cost of creating the  
infrastructure of the system of technical operation (A. 3.1);  
The method of calculation of the costs of system  
maintenance (one technical service system (TSS)) (A. 3.2)  
. The method of calculating the cost of initial training of  
personnel for one instance of high-tech products (A. 3.3)  
. The method of calculating the cost of purchasing a set  
of spare parts for one instance of a high-tech product (A. 3.4)  
The standard provides a method of calculating the  
specific direct costs of, namely:  
2
.
1
2
.
.
Specific costs of planned maintenance;  
Unit costs for resource recovery (replacement the  
3
parts of the product due to the development of their assigned  
resource (service life));  
4
3
4
.
.
Unit costs of unscheduled maintenance;  
Unit costs of personnel remuneration.  
The following indicators are used to estimate the initial  
maintenance costs:  
3
.1 Description of Cost Calculation Methods  
А.3 - Cost calculation methods:  
1
.
The cost of creating the infrastructure of the  
А.3.1The cost of creating the infrastructure of the technical  
operation system for one instance of the product is calculated  
by the formula:  
technical operation system;  
2
3
4
.
.
.
Acquisition costs maintenance;  
The costs for initial training for technical personnel;  
Acquisition costs for the spare parts to ensure the  
ꢔ
ꢕꢁꢂꢃ  
ꢀꢗꢔ  
ꢁ
ꢂꢃ  
ꢁꢂꢃ  
(А.1)  
ꢀ
required value of the coefficient of readiness of the sample  
products.  
ꢓ
ꢖ∑  
ꢐꢑꢒꢄꢅ  
ꢕꢃꢁ  
Where NИНФ - the amount of infrastructure needed to  
perform Maintenance and repair of the Park of the considered  
A priori data for calculation.  
А.2.1 Quantitative parameter:  
samples of product; Nфи -average number of product  
the Park;  
5 - average number export products samples in  
ꢁꢂꢃ  
samples in the Park; ꢀ  
- the cost of the i-th infrastructure  
A.3.2 The cost of the maintenance system for one copy of the  
PVN is calculated by the formula:  
0.9 (high degree of readiness) - the required  
coefficient of availability.  
ꢔ
ꢕ ꢄꢅ  
ꢘ
ꢀꢗꢔ ꢀꢗꢔ  
ꢄꢅ  
ꢄꢅꢊꢋꢃꢁꢌꢖꢙꢀ ꢄꢅꢌ(А.2)  
ꢓ
ꢖꢊ∑  
ꢐꢑꢒꢄꢅ  
А.2.2 Data on technical operation system infrastructure  
ꢕꢃꢁ  
and equipment:  
ꢄꢅ  
NИНФ - number of infrastructure facilities required  
where  
- the unit price of one hundredi-th type;  
ꢀ
to perform technical service and repair (TSP) of the Park of  
NСТО - the number of types of technical service system  
the considered product samples;  
(TSS)necessary to perform technical service and repair  
ꢁ
ꢂꢃ- the cost of the i-th infrastructure;  
(TSP) of the Park of the considered samples  
ꢀ
ꢄꢅ  
NСТО - number of types of technical service  
ꢘꢀ ꢊꢋꢃꢁꢌ- the number of units of technical service system  
system (TSS) required to perform technical service and  
repair (TSP) of the Park of the considered product samples;  
(TSS) i-th type required for maintenance of copies of  
product.  
NСТО -number of types of maintenance systems  
SRT) required to perform technical service and repair  
А.3.3 The cost of initial training of the personnel for a single  
instance of MPP is calculated by the formula:  
(
(
TSP) of the Park of the considered product samples  
ꢕ ꢇꢈꢉ  
ꢄꢅ  
ꢇꢈꢉ  
ꢐꢑꢒꢄꢅ  
ꢔ
ꢖꢊ∑ꢀꢗꢔ ꢆꢀꢇꢈꢉꢊꢋꢃꢁꢌꢖꢙ ꢀꢅ ꢍꢎꢏꢌ(А.3)  
- the unit price of one technical service  
ꢓ
ꢀ
ꢕꢃꢁ  
system (TSS) of the i-th type.  
where NФИ - the average number of samples of equipment  
in the Park (at the facility);  
NСПЕЦ - the number of specialties of engineering and  
technical staff required to perform technical service and  
repair (TSP);  
А.2.3 Data on training needs:  
NСПЕЦ -the number of specialties of engineering  
staff required to perform technical service and repair (TSP)  
of the considered product samples  
373  
Journal of Environmental Treatment Techniques  
2019, Volume 7, Issue 3, Pages: 370-376  
ꢇꢈꢉ  
order to reduce the product servicing cost on the territory of  
the Customer (Indonesia):  
ꢆꢀ  
ꢊꢋꢃꢁꢌ- number of specialists of the i-th specialty  
required for MRO copies;  
ꢅꢍꢎꢏ  
ꢙꢀ  
-the cost of training specialist i-th specialty.  
А.3.4 The cost of purchasing kit parts for a single instance of  
MPP is calculated by the formula  
ꢔ
ꢕꢛꢁ  
ꢀꢗꢔ  
ꢂꢚꢏ  
ꢖ(∑ ꢙꢀ ꢖꢋꢀꢂꢚꢏ)(А.4)  
ꢓ
ꢐꢑꢒꢄꢅ  
ꢕꢃꢁ  
where ꢋꢀꢂꢚꢏ- the quantity set of products (SP) of the i-th  
type in the set of spare parts;  
ꢂꢚꢏ  
ꢋꢀ  
(ꢜꢓꢝꢞꢞꢋ)-calculate on the basis of the required value.  
The effective usage of high-tech products at the site of  
operation is possible, in the presence of trained technical  
personnel. When supplying products for export, options for  
training technical personnel of the customer's country are  
considered.  
The method of calculating the cost of initial training of  
personnel for one instance of a high-tech product is described  
in paragraph (A. 3.3).  
Figure 1: Result of calculation. List of specialties and number of  
specialists for technical service and repair (TSP)  
Table 5: List of specialties and number of specialists for maintenance  
and repair  
Profession  
engineering and  
technical  
The cost of  
training  
specialist i-th  
specialty  
5000  
10000  
15000  
25000  
40000  
2000  
8000  
3000  
100000  
The cost of  
training,  
thousands  
($)  
15000  
20000  
4
Modeling the Situation  
Total  
profession  
Let us assume that the maintenance of one high-tech  
product at the facility of operation of the customer's country  
is required: the number of specialties of engineering staff  
required to perform maintenance and repair; the number of  
specialists i-th specialty required for maintenance and repair;  
the cost of training i-th specialty (table 4)  
personnel  
profession1  
profession2  
profession3  
profession4  
profession5  
profession6  
profession7  
profession8  
professionN  
3
2
1
5
4
3
1
1
1
15000  
125000  
160000  
6000  
8000  
3000  
Table 4: List of specialties and number of specialists for technical  
service and repair (TSP)  
The cost of  
training  
specialist i-  
th  
The cost  
of  
Profession of  
engineering and  
technical  
100000  
Total specialists  
training,  
thousands  
($)  
4
52000  
-
total of all  
specialists  
personnel  
N
СПЕЦ  
21  
specialty,($)  
profession1  
Profession2  
profession3  
profession4  
profession5  
profession6  
profession7  
professionN  
5000  
10000  
15000  
25000  
40000  
2000  
8000  
5
3
2
7
8
4
1
1
25000  
30000  
30000  
175000  
320000  
8000  
8000  
ꢇꢈꢉ  
ꢙ
21523,81($)  
ꢐꢑꢒꢄꢅ  
100000  
100000  
6
96000  
-
N
СПЕЦ  
31  
total of all specialists  
ꢇꢈꢉ  
ꢐꢑꢒꢄꢅ  
ꢙ
22451,61($)  
In relation to the number of increasing specialties of  
engineering personnel per unit, while maintaining the cost of  
training and reducing the number of specialists, the total cost  
is reduced. Therefore, the optimal price will be determined by  
the lowest cost of training the necessary and sufficient  
number of trained personnel.  
Figure 2: Result of calculation. Result of calculation. List of  
specialties and number of specialists for technical service and repair  
(TSP), the increase in per unit  
1
.Prepare more engineering and technical personnel  
5
Results and Discussion  
specialties;  
Mathematical modeling of product, service cost is  
2
.Minimize the number of trained specialists for  
researched in the article. The method of calculating the initial  
personnel training cost reveals regularity. The next steps are  
required in terms of reducing the personnel training cost in  
maintenance and repair of specific products of one series (for  
example: SU series aircraft).  
374  
Journal of Environmental Treatment Techniques  
2019, Volume 7, Issue 3, Pages: 370-376  
3
.Use the calculation methods recommended by the  
the cost calculating for the science-intensive products  
support. The ways for identifying unnecessary cost with  
maintaining the product quality performance at the facility  
are examples in the article. This way may take effect to the  
defense products cooperation between Russia and Indonesia.  
Authors O.L. Mnatsakanyan, D.Y. Altimentova and D.V.  
Agaltsova, it is proposed to use research materials in the  
educational process of higher education institutions (10).  
Authors S.V. Veretekhina et al. conduct research to identify  
effective methods of calculation or economic and technical  
areas (18,20). Rector of Russian state social university  
(Moscow) of N.B. Pochinok et al. conduct a socio-economic  
study of approaches to the study of consumer behavior in the  
market (11). Development of interactive electronic  
documentation was carried out by the developer of the  
technical University by the authors S.V. Veretekhina and  
V.V. Veretekhin and authors S.V. Melnikov et al. (9,17). The  
authors of the publication Express their gratitude to the  
authors K.I. Erusheva, K.Yu. Kolybanov and I.R. Tishaeva,  
V. Redkous and A. Sergeev, E.A. Sobolev et al., E.V.  
Vishnevskaya, T.B. Klimova and I.V. Bogomazova, O.  
Zhdanovich et al. (5,12,13,21,22). The efforts of these  
scientists formed the basis for further research. To assess the  
multiplicative effect for the region (Indonesia), the authors  
recommend the use of evolutionary motors calculations  
described in the works of the authors of S.V. Veretekhina et  
al. (19) The collective works of the authors are of practical  
importance, relevant at the present stage of development of  
international relations between Russia and Indonesia.  
Russian national standard GOST R 56130.  
Therefore, if you apply the calculations according to the  
recommended methods (A. 3.1 - A. 3.4), it is possible to  
conduct a comprehensive cost analyze of material, financial,  
labor and time resources.  
Information support of the product at the facility  
includes:  
1
2
.Number of exported products;  
.Frequency of delivery of spare parts and equipment  
under warranty and post-warranty repair contracts;  
3
4
.The time period of service,  
.The complexity of the service.  
5
.1 The Complexity of the Tinning is Calculated According  
to the Established Formulas  
Therefore, if we take for the maximum-the necessary  
amount of training of technical personnel (table 4) as 100 %,  
respectively, we can calculate the percentage:  
ꢠꢝꢡꢠꢢꢣꢤꢝꢖꢝꢥꢥꢦ  
ꢟꢓ  
ꢓꢩꢡꢣꢤꢪꢦ  
ꢠꢠꢧꢡꢝꢣꢨꢝ  
5
.2 Conclusion According to the Calculations  
With an increasing number of students in engineering  
specialty and decreasing the technical personnel in the total  
number of specialists of maintenance and repair services from  
3
1 to 21 people, the total cost is reduced by  
00%-95.87%=4.13 %.  
The total savings in 4.13 % of costs only in the  
1
calculation of A. The initial training cost of the personnel for  
one copy of the product is a significant amount. In monetary  
terms, it is 927, 8 thousand dollars. Studies were aimed to  
identify unnecessary costs with maintaining the quality of  
performance for the product at the facility. The calculations  
show the effectiveness of standardized methods usage.  
Application of standards of integrated logistics supported by  
foreign customers allow to provide cost calculations for the  
effective usage of high-tech products with acceptable cost for  
their life cycle at the facility. The main purpose of this  
publication is to develop methodological provisions for the  
economic processes analyze and systems based on the usage  
of the economic and mathematical methods and tools. The  
authors put forward for discussion the hypothesis that before  
buying complex science-intensive equipment, it is advisable  
to carry out complex calculations and simulate costs, to  
determine quantitative and qualitative indicators.  
References  
1. Aktymbayeva, A.S., Koshkimbayeva, U.T., Zhakupova, A.A.,  
Alimgaziyeva, N.K. & Amir, B.M. E-commerce evaluation and  
e-business trends. International Journal of Innovative  
Technologies in Economy. 2018; 1(13): 59-63.  
2
.
Barinova, V.A., Sorokina, A.V., Zemtsov, S.P., Bortnik, I.M. &  
Infimovskaya, S.Yu. Analysis of competitive factors of domestic  
high-tech companies. Innovations. 2015; 3: 25-31.  
Blyaeva, E.V. &Gavrilov, A.V. DSL-based approach for  
industry technological schemes design. IT-Standart. 2017; 1(1):  
40-43.  
3
.
4
.
Çiftci S. Letter to Editor: Prognostic Value of Mean Platelet  
Volume and Platelet to Lymphocyte Ratio in Laryngeal  
Carcinoma.  
https://doi.org/10.5799/jcei.328537.  
J
Clin  
Exp  
Invest.  
2016;7(4):294-5.  
5
6
.
.
Erusheva, K.I., Kolybanov, K.Yu. & Tishaeva, I.R. Functional  
modeling of the process of choosing the best available  
technique.Fine Chemical Technologies. 2017; 12(4): 98-105.  
Farahani MD, Aghajani H. Identification of Potential  
6
Conclusions  
In conclusion, emphasis should be placed on the needs in  
Groundwater Zones Using RS and GIS, 5-8. Journal of  
Research in Science, Engineering and Technology. 2013;1(04).  
the standardized calculation methods. Russian national  
standards offer improved methods of calculating unit cost.  
Modeling of processes allows to find the optimal amount.  
7. Khitskov, E.A., Veretekhina, S.V., Medvedeva, A.V.,  
Mnatsakanyan, O.L., Shmakova, E.G. & Kotenev, A. Digital  
transformation of society: Problems entering in the digital  
economy, in Eurasian Journal of Analytical Chemistry.  
The Russian state social university (Moscow) has  
a
cooperation agreement with Indonesia. RSSU qualify  
Indonesian students in the technological cluster of the  
information technologies faculty. The article approves the  
hypothesis that the exported high-tech product price does not  
dominate the market however information support  
technologies of knowledge-intensive products are dominant  
on the object of operation. Authors give practical examples of  
2
017;5:855-873.  
8
.
Kommersant. Indonesia is not going to cancel the acquisition of  
SU-35 fighters - an interview with TASS the Head of the  
Indonesian Military Department of Ryamizard Ryacudu, October  
2
0,  
2018.  
Available  
at:  
https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/3777544  
9. Melnikov, S.V., Trifonov, T.T, Melnikov, B.F., Pivneva, S.V. &  
Trifonov, M.A. Еvaluation of algorithms for the calculation of  
375  
Journal of Environmental Treatment Techniques  
2019, Volume 7, Issue 3, Pages: 370-376  
the distance of rows of DNA. News of higher educational  
institutions. Volgaregion. Physical and mathematical Sciences.  
2
015; 2(34): 57-67.  
1
1
0. Mnatsakanyan, O.L., Altimentova, D.Y. & Agaltsova, D.V. New  
educational results achieving by means of distance learning  
system. Human capital. 2017; 2: 19-21.  
1. Pochinok, N.B., Vinogradova, M.V., Babakaev, S.V. & Korolev,  
V.A. The socio-economic study of approaches to the study of  
consumer behavior in the service sector. Social policy and  
sociology. 2016; 1(11): 24-34.  
1
1
2. Redkous, V. &Sergeev, A. Issues of Interaction between the  
Law–Enforcement Agencies and Civil Society Institutes in the  
Strategy of National Security of the Russian Federation.The Law  
and Right. 2016; 2: 154–156.  
3. Sobolev, E.A., Abdulgalimov, A.R., Razlivinskaya, S.V.  
&
Kornyushko, V.F. Principles of corporate information system  
for logistics management of petrochemical enterprises.Fine  
Chemical Technologies. 2017;1: 85-92.  
1
1
1
4. Sudov, E.V., Levin, A.I., Petrov, A.N., Petrov, A.V. & Borozdin,  
D.N. Analysis of the logistics support theory and practicet. 2014.  
URL:https://elibrary.ru/item.asp?id=28428964.  
5. Sudov, E.V., Petrov, A.N., Petrov, A.V., Osaev, A.T. &  
Serebryanskiy, S.A. Technologies of integrated logistics support  
in the life cycle of aircraft. Moscow: Editus.2018.  
6. Tereso, A., Ribeiro, P., & Cardoso, M.. An Automated  
Framework for the Integration between EVM and Risk  
Management. Journal of Information Systems Engineering &  
Management. 2018; 3(1):03.  
1
1
7. Veretekhina, S.V. & Veretekhin, V.V. Modern methods of  
preparation of interactive electronic engineering specifications in  
the applied specialized software. Materials of the  
VI International  
research  
and  
practice  
conference Science and Education. Munich. 2014; 508–513.  
8. Veretekhina, S.V., Karyagina, T.V., Potekhina, E.V.,  
Nakhratova, E.E., Pronkina, T.V.  
&
Makushkin, S.A.  
Mathematical methods of an estimation of economic efficiency  
of investments and the sequence of execution of starts of  
investment on the example of the national technology initiative  
of Russian Federation. Modern journal of language teaching  
methods. 2018; 8(6): 84-100.  
1
9. Veretekhina, S.V., Shinkareva, O.V., Kozhaev, J.P.,  
Telepchenkova, N.V., Kuznetsova, E.A. & Zaitseva, N.A.  
Evaluation methodology of the multiplier effect for the region as  
the result of the cluster formation. Eurasian Journal of  
Analytical Chemistry. 2017; 12(1): 1-22.  
2
2
0. Veretekhina, S.V., Zhuravlyov, M.S., Shmakova, E.G., Soldatov,  
A.A., Kotenev, A.V., Kashirin, S.V. & Medvedeva, A.V. Analog  
sound signal digitalization and processing. Modern Journal of  
Language Teaching Methods. 2018; 8(3): 39-54.  
1. Vishnevskaya, E.V., Klimova, T.B. & Bogomazova, I.V. The  
use of modern mobile applications to increase the tourist  
attractiveness of the territory. In the collection: Actual problems  
of economy in the conditions of reforming of modern society.  
Materials of the III international scientific-practical conference.  
2
015; 234-238.  
2
2. Zhdanovich, O., Kornyushko, V., Ivanchuk, I. & Kostrov, A.  
The estimate methodic of business process management system  
readiness level to information technology introduction. Applied  
Informatics2014; 50: 14-22.  
376